Nature Blog Network
Showing posts with label Hydrothermal Vents. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Hydrothermal Vents. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 21, 2007

Dissertation Blogging, Part 5: New Species of Alvinocaris

In preparation for my comprehensive examination next week and because its International Dissertation Writing Month, I will be posting my thesis proposal as I madly try to finish it all in time over the next few days. Feel free to question, correct, nitpick, criticize (constructively, I'm in a fragile state right now!), comment, praise me and make suggestions for improvement. And yes, I'm freakin' out!!!!

__________________________________________________________

A new species of Alvinocaris (Crustacea: Decapoda: Alvinocarididae) from hydrothermal vents at the Lau Basin, southwest Pacific, and a key to the species of Alvinocarididae


Alvinocaris sp. nov. on Bathymodiolus brevior. The little limpet is Lepetodrilus schrolli. Photo copyright C.R. Fisher/Ridge2000.


My coauthor from Station Biologique de Roscoff and I have described a new species caridean shrimp in the family Alvinocarididae. This family of shrimp was split off from the Bresiliidae in late 1990's and forms a monophyletic unit that is adapted to deep sea reducing environments such as seeps and vents. To date, no other alvinocaridid has been confirmed from a non-reducing environment. Our species is very characteristic from other alvinocaridids in the shape of the telson and armature of the pereopods, or the legs. I just got the reviews from this paper on Monday and will be making the revisions, therefore I will not go into too much detail until it is published. Expect a full blown review later, but until then here is the abstract as it was submitted.

Abstract: We describe Alvinocaris (have to wait till its published to see the name!) sp. n. from hydrothermal fields at the East-Lau Spreading centre (ELSC). This species is larger than other alvinocaridids at the ELSC and appears to preferentially inhabit mussel beds composed of Bathymodiolus brevior. A. (name removed) differs from all known Alvinocaris by a distinctive, deep notch mesially on the telson. Suites of morphological characters separate A. (na na nana na) from other alvinocaridids. We analyze the degree of morphological variation in A. (yakity yak) and affinities of the Pacific Alvinocaris. A. (can't touch this) is also fit into a phylogeny of the Alvinocarididae using the mitochondrial COI gene and phylogenetic relationships are discussed. A key to the species of the family Alvinocarididae is included with locality information.

Dissertation Blogging, Part 4: Vent Food Web Structure

In preparation for my comprehensive examination next week and because its International Dissertation Writing Month, I will be posting my thesis proposal as I madly try to finish it all in time over the next few days. Feel free to question, correct, nitpick, criticize (constructively, I'm in a fragile state right now!), comment, praise me and make suggestions for improvement. And yes, I'm freakin' out!!!!

Part 1: Introduction
Part 2: Seep Primary Production of POM
Part 3: Community Structure at Lau Back-Arc Basin Vents
__________________________________________________________
Food web structure at the Eastern-Lau Spreading Center

Vent crab, Austinograea alayseae, lying in wait in a chimney crevice? The shrimp are Chorocaris vandoverae. Photo copyright C.R. Fisher/Ridge2000.


It is established that chemoautotrophic primary production is utilized other inhabitants of vent ecosystems. This is evidenced by stable isotope ratios and gut content analysis of selected non-chemoautotrophic fauna. Stable isotope ratios provide a powerful tool to understand trophic relationships based on the predictable fractionation of elements with trophic level. Coupled with mixing model, stable isotopes can show minimum input of a source of primary production into an ecosystem in relation to other sources.

In this chapter I propose to construct a trophic model of this nested (within substrate) 3-foundation species ecosystem. A paper currently in peer review gave hint at some differences in the combined use of carbon and nitrogen stable isotopes in separating out signatures between the three chemoautotrophic foundation species. I will investigate the carbon, nitrogen and sulfur stable isotope composition of whole communities to understand resource partitioning, trophic guild structure and food web interactions in the ELSC ecosystem. Selected fauna from the periphery of the foundation species’ communities will be used to study how chemoautotrophic primary production is utilized away from the source.

• Null hypothesis 1: There is no difference in stable isotope ratios between chemoautotrophic foundation species
o Response: carbon, nitrogen and sulfur stable isotope ratios
o Predictor: foundation species type
• Null hypothesis 2: Stable isotopes ratios will be similar between substrate types for each foundation species
o Response: carbon, nitrogen and sulfur stable isotope ratios
o Predictor: foundation species type by substrate type
• Null hypothesis 3: There is no relationship of associated fauna’s stable isotope ratios to that of the chemoautotrophic foundation species.
o Response: carbon, nitrogen and sulfur stable isotope ratios
o Predictor: foundation species type
• Null hypothesis 4: Stable isotope ratios are similar between trophic guilds (i.e. no apparent structure is present)
o Response: carbon, nitrogen and sulfur stable isotope ratios
o Predictor: trophic guild level
• Other objectives:
o Use a mixing model to determine percentage of vent-derived nutrients used by associated fauna, using the chemoautotrophic fauna as proxies for the vent end-member(s)
o Form a model of the food web and trophic guild structure.

Tuesday, November 20, 2007

Dissertation Blogging, Part 3: Community Structure at Lau Back-Arc Basin Vents

In preparation for my comprehensive examination next week and because its International Dissertation Writing Month, I will be posting my thesis proposal as I madly try to finish it all in time over the next few days. Feel free to question, correct, nitpick, criticize (constructively, I'm in a fragile state right now!), comment, praise me and make suggestions for improvement. And yes, I'm freakin' out!!!!

Part 1: Introduction
Part 2: Seep Primary Production of POM
___________________________________________________________________
Community Structure Associated With Chemoautotrophic Foundation Species at the Eastern-Lau Spreading Center in Relation to Stress and Substrate

Only one paper has addressed the ecology here, published by Desbruyères et al. (1994) it was based on targeted collections and video observations of the North Fiji and Lau back-arc basins. More recently, Henry et al. (submitted) found significant differences between the physiological tolerances of the ELSC chemoautotrophs in laboratory experiments while Podowski et al. (submitted) have found significant differences in the in situ thermo-chemical environment associated between various ELSC community types including the three foundation species’ communities. Communities associated with A. hessleri are exposed to high H2S, low O2 and high temperatures, while communities associated with B. brevior are exposed to low H2S, higher O2 and much lower temperatures. The thermo-chemical tolerances of I. nautilei overlap these two extremes. This gradient is apparent in their stratification, often resembling a "bull's eye" pattern around a vent opening with A. hessleri at the center surrounded by I. nautilei and then B. brevior.

My work seeks to understand the structure of chemoautotrophy-based communities at the Eastern-Lau Spreading Center (ELSC) in greater detail through quantitative sampling of foundation species. Two main questions are guiding this research: 1) What is the role of substrate in community structure? and 2) Are communities associated with chemoautotrophic foundation species structured along stress gradients? The data I have collected to address these questions include biometric data and abundance, in addition to mass and shell volume of a subset of the three chemoautotrophic foundation fauna from each collection. All associated fauna from quantitative collections of each community type were identified, enumerated and weighed for biomass.

The first question is derived from the observation that there appear to be wider diffuse venting communities on andesitic substrate, whereas on basaltic substrates venting appeared more localized. These two lava types are closely related but differ in concentrations of metals (i.e. iron, magnesium, silica) and physical properties (i.e. permeability, fragility). Additionally, polymetalic sulfides created as a result of hydrothermal venting provide a third substrate, likely the most extreme with reference to temperature and exposure to metal, hydrogen sulfide and oxygen concentrations. Two of our four study sites are basaltic while the other two are andesitic, but sulfides occur at all four sites in the way “chimneys” (see picture below) though the ones I was able to obtain collections from are only from the two basaltic sites.

Hydrothermal chimney built up from deposition of polymetalic sulfides. Encrusted with vent fauna, dark snail appears to be all I. nautilei and mussel is B. brevior. Photo copyright C.R. Fisher/Ridge2000.

• Null hypothesis 1: Mussels are in the same physiological condition regardless of substrate
o Response: condition index (g AFDW/internal shell volume)
o Predictor: substrate type
[figure and part of discussion removed]
The data suggests that mussels from andesitic communities are in better physiological condition over basalt and sulfide communities.

• Null hypothesis 2: There is no difference in biomass and abundance of chemoautotrophic fauna between substrates
o Response: biomass (kg/m2) and abundance (No. of individuals)
o Predictor: substrate type
[figure and part of discussion removed]
Biomass was not significantly different between substrate and between site. Abundance is significant only between andesitic and sulfide substrates and weakly significant between Kilo Moana and Tu’i Malila. The null hypothesis is only weakly rejected in certain cases, perhaps due to uneven sampling or high variability within a substrate type or site.

• Null hypothesis 3: There is no difference in the diversity (excluding chemoautotrophic fauna) between substrates
o Responses: species richness, evenness, Shannon index, Fisher’s alpha
o Predictor: substrate type
[figure and part of discussion removed]
The use of the various community indices suggest that andesitic communities are higher in diversity and lower in dominance.

Null hypothesis 4: Community similarity is the same across substrate type
o Responses: presence/absence, abundance, biomass, trophic guild biomass
o Predictors: substrate type, community type
o Method: Bray-Curtis similarity cluster analysis, multi-dimensional scaling
[figure and part of discussion removed]
Andesitic sites cluster together with varying chemoautotrophic foundation species biomass, suggesting that andesitic communities of different heterogeneities tend to be assembled similarly. All sulfide communities analyzed are from hydrothermal vents at basaltic sites, which they tended to cluster together with. ABE has a lot of overlap with the basaltic/sulfide sites. Tu’i Malila has little no overlap with basaltic sites and little overlap with ABE, the other andesitic site. Kilo Moana, TowCam and ABE are all relatively closer together while Tu’i Malila is farther south and shallower. These plots suggest that distance may be more of a factor in determining community structure than substrate type.

The second question makes the assumption that each foundation species occupies a certain niche on a stress spectrum. As previously described, the work of Henry et al. (submitted) and Podowski et al. (submitted) has shown a well-defined gradient of thermo-chemical tolerance both in lab experiments and in situ thermo-chemical sensing of the environments occupied by the three foundation species. I will test whether their respective communities are structured according to foundation species thermo-chemical tolerances as a proxy for environmental stress. To do this, I assign the highest stress to communities associated with A. hessleri, intermediate stress to communities associated with I. nautilei and the lowest stress to communities associated with B. brevior. Several samples were either chosen as communities of mixed foundation species or discovered upon retrieval to be mixed communities. These communities are analyzed separately and considered as an intermediate between A. hessleri/I. nautilei and I. nautilei/B. brevior communities.

"Bulls eye" pattern of chemoautotrophic foundation species around a fissure with diffusive venting. Photo copyright C.R. Fisher.

• Null hypothesis 1: There is no difference in diversity metrics (excluding chemoautotrophic fauna) between chemoautotrophic community type
o Responses: species richness, evenness, Shannon index, Fisher’s alpha
o Predictor: foundation species type

• Null hypothesis 2: There is no relationship between diversity and biological characteristics of foundation species.
o Responses: species richness, evenness, Shannon index, Fisher’s alpha
o Predictors: shell length, shell volume, biomass, percentage of most dominant fauna

• Null hypothesis 3: There is no difference in the diversity, abundance and biomass of mussel communities between different physiological condition indices.
o Response: species richness, evenness, Shannon index, Fisher’s alpha
o Predictors: condition index (g AFDW/internal shell volume)

• Null hypothesis 4: There is no community structure across foundation species type.
o Response: presence/absence, abundance, biomass of non-chemoautotrophic foundation species
o Predictors: foundation species type

• Null hypothesis 5: Within mussel bed communities, there is no relationship between diversity, biomass and abundance of the associated community to the mussel’s physiological condition.
o Response: species richness, evenness, Shannon index, Fisher’s alpha
o Predictors: physiological condition indices

• Other objectives:
o Plot shell length frequencies to test if there are patterns to recruitment within and across site and substrate type
o Report sampling effort using rarefaction
o Test whether taxonomic diversity is significantly different across site, substrate and foundation species type
o Explore the use of additional multivariate techniques
o Compare results and species composition to other western Pacific back-arc basins to discern any patterns, as well as to other hydrothermal vent sites.

Literature Cited

Bergquist DC, Fleckenstein C, Szalai EB, Knisel J, Fisher CR (2004) Environment drives physiological variability in the cold seep mussel Bathymodiolus childressi. Limnology and Oceanography 49:706-715

Desbruyères D, Alayse-Danet A-M, Ohta S, Scientific Parties of BIOLAU and STARMER cruises (1994) Deep-sea hydrothermal communities in Southwestern Pacific back-arc basins (the North Fiji and Lau Basins): composition, microdistribution and food web. Marine Geology 116:227-242

Fisher CR, Childress JJ, Arp AJ, Brooks JM, Distel DL, Favuzzi JA, Felbeck H, Hessler RR, Johnson KS, Kennicutt II MC, Macko SA, Newton A, Powell MA, Somero GN, Soto T (1988) Microhabitat variation in the hydrothermal vent mussel, Bathymodiolus thermophilus, at the Rose Garden vent on the Galapagos Rift. Deep-Sea Research 35:1769-1791

Smith KL (1985) Deep-sea hydrothermal vent mussels: nutritional state and distribution at the Galapagos Rift. Ecology 66:1067-1080

Thursday, November 15, 2007

Dissertation Blogging, Part 1: Introduction

*This marks my 200th post. In preparation for comprehensive examination in less than 2 weeks and because its International Dissertation Writing Month, I will be posting my thesis proposal as I madly try to finish it all in time over the next few days. Feel free to question, correct, nitpick, criticize (constructively, I'm in a fragile state right now!), comment, praise me and make suggestions for improvement. And yes, I'm freakin' out!!!!
______________________________________________________________________________________
Biodiversity of Chemosynthetic Communities at the Eastern-Lau Spreading Centre

Many communities persist due the presence of a foundation species. Dayton (1972) defined a foundation species as an large, influential species that has a positive effect on community inhabitants through modifying environmental parameters, species interactions and resource availability. It is hypothesized that foundation fauna can ameliorate abiotic stress by modifying the chemical and physical environment (Bruno et al. 2003). The refuge provided by the foundation species increases abundance, biomass and diversity of other associated species (Bruno & Bertness 2001). Many chemoautotrophic megafauna at hydrothermal vents are foundation fauna that live in environments with high concentrations of toxic chemicals, heavy metals, high temperatures and low oxygen concentrations. Chemoautotrophs may modify the physical and chemical habitat (Johnson et al. 1994, Shank et al. 1998) and provide structural heterogeneity (Govenar & Fisher 2007), making the local environment more amenable to less tolerant colonizers (Shank et al. 1998). My research aims to test hypotheses relating environmental stress to the species composition and diversity of chemosynthetic communities at the Eastern-Lau Spreading Center (ELSC). Additionally, I will investigate the trophic ecology and food web structure between communities associated with three chemoautotrophic foundation species.


This thesis work is part of a larger project investigating the geology, chemistry, microbiology and ecology of deep-sea hydrothermal vents at the ELSC. Back-arc basins are the result of a complex plate tectonics setting where two or more oceanic plates converge with one plate subducting beneath the other(s). The friction caused by the subducting plates’ movement melts the rock along the plate boundary causing a volcanic arc to form on the overlaying plate. On the backside of that arc, a spreading centre is created as a result of the extensional forces of the subduction. Where back-arc spreading occurs, the crust is thin and fragile (see figure below). Seawater seeps down into cracks and fissures and comes into contact with super-heated rock. The seawater is heated and rises, carrying reduced chemicals and heavy metals in solution, which exits the crust at the seafloor and precipitates out of solution creating hydrothermal vent chimneys. Bacteria have evolved metabolic pathways to utilize the energy from oxidizing some of these reduced chemicals such as sulfides and methane. Furthermore, several metazoans have evolved a symbiosis with these bacteria with the result being abundant communities surrounding many vents worldwide.


The hydrothermal vent ecosystem is based upon chemosynthetic primary production and offers an opportunity to empirically test various measures of the diversity-stress hypothesis. At the ELSC, 3 major chemoautotrophic foundation species occur in dense aggregations: the snails Alviniconcha hessleri and Ifremeria nautilei and the mussel Bathymodiolus brevior. Henry et al. (submitted) have found clear differences in the thresholds for maximum H2S and minimum O2 concentrations and maximum temperatures for the three foundation species. Podowski et al. (submitted) have found significant differences in situ of H2S, O2 and temperature measurements between each of these community types, supporting the hypothesis that each foundation species occupies a specific thermo-chemical microhabitat. Furthermore, they occupy a gradient of stress, similar to a “bull’s eye” pattern, with A. hessleri in the highest stress environment (high H2S, low O2, high temp.), B. brevior in lowest stress environment (low H2S, higher O2 and near ambient temp.) and I. nautilei occupying an intermediate position with overlap on both ends. This well-defined gradient allows me to test the relationship between species diversity and stress.

Bathymodiolus brevior (Mytilidae)

At vents, stress can be ameliorated by chemoautotrophic foundation species by removal of sulfide from the environment (Johnson et al. 1988, Johnson et al. 1994). Mussel beds in low vent flow at the Galapagos Rift Zone vents have been shown to diffuse venting laterally and removal experiments have shown that sulfide concentrations above the mussel bed are lower pre-removal (Johnson et al. 1994). Stress reduction, by way of vent flow diffusion and sulfide removal, should increase with biomass of the foundation species if facilitation were an important factor in structuring communities associated with a foundation species. I hypothesize that diversity should increase with foundation species biomass (greater stress reduction) to a point where the response curve asymptotes at the maximum local species diversity. If competitive exclusion played a role in structuring these communities, then according to theory diversity is predicted to be greatest at intermediate levels of stress (Bruno et al. 2003). Since I. nautilei inhabits an intermediate position in stress tolerance, I would expect to see its associated community have the highest mean diversity.

The ELSC is further characterized by two different substrate types: lava tends to exhibit more basaltic characteristics in the north and andesitic in the south. The physical and chemical properties of these lava types are subtly different, but may have implications for how the hydrothermal venting regime is distributed over space. Preliminary evidence suggests that andesite, a more pliable and porous lava type, diffuses venting laterally more than basalt. This has implications for the fauna living on each lava type. This observation leads to the prediction that communities on andesite hosted substrate will have higher biomass and greater diversity than communities on basalt hosted substrate. The effect of substrate may be confounded by lateral diffusion by beds of mussels, and presumably snails. Even so, the greater diffusivity of andesite may act synergistically the diffusive activity of the mussel and snail beds to increase the amount of habitat that can support their respective associated communities.

Ifremeria nautilei (Provannidae)

The communities associated with these foundation fauna are poorly documented and the biological literature for this area consists mainly of taxonomic descriptions and video observations. Rapid progress is being made in understanding the ELSC communities due to the 2005 and 2006 expeditions to the area. Podowski et al. (submitted) built upon the limitations imposed by the laboratory setting of Henry et al.’s (submitted) physiological work of the chemoautotrophic species by measuring in situ chemical concentrations and temperature measurements of communities as a whole. Though their findings were novel and furthered our understanding of these communities, but Podowski et al.’s work was limited to the 2-dimensional view of the surface of the communities. Thus, diversity was biased against smaller fauna and those that lived within the foundation species’ matrix and not at the surface. Inferences on abundance, biomass, diversity and trophic interactions to the communities as a whole are thus limited. In order to understand how the communities associated with chemoautotrophic foundation species are structured, I collected 36 quantitative whole-community samples nested within site, which is nested within substrate (basaltic or andesitic). Each community is based on collections of one of three chemoautotrophic foundation species, confirmed upon retrieval as dominants in terms of abundance and biomass. Mixed communities, defined arbitrarily as the dominant foundation species composing 75% or less of the total foundation species abundance or biomass, were collected a priori and discovered a posteriori upon retrieval. I recognize that sampling may be biased by collecting from sites where the research team concentrated most of their multidisciplinary studies and by collecting the communities observed to be best collected by our sampling device. Sampling is thus haphazard and not random.

Alviniconcha hessleri (Provannidae)

The hydrothermal vent food web is structured upon bacterially-derived chemoautotrophic primary production (Jannasch 1985). Bacteria may be free-living or in an endosymbiosis with a wide range invertebrates (Childress & Fisher 1992). There is evidence for the cycling of chemoautotrophic-derived nutrients through consumers at vents and exportation of these nutrients outside the vent system (Van Dover & Fry 1989, Fisher et al. 1994, Van Dover & Fry 1994, Bergquist et al. 2007). Tunnicliffe (1991) constructed the first general food web model of the vent ecosystem which was later expounded upon by Bergquist et al. (2007) for the Juan de Fuca vent ecosystem. Their models included 3 producer pools (subsurface bacteria, bacterial mats on the surface and symbiotic bacteria) and 4 consumer pools (grazers, scavengers/detrivores, suspension feeders, predators and endosymbiotic hosts) interacting through four trophic pathways. Bergquist et al. (2007) recognized the utility of investigating trophic structure in a quantitative community setting in order to compare those results to community characteristics, but their analyses were limited to only one community. In order to better understand the relationship between community characteristics and trophic structure, I will analyze stable isotopes of fauna from quantitative collections on both andesitic and basaltic substrates.

While identifying and enumerating species for the community ecology portion of my research, I became very interested in systematics. This is due to my own personal fascination with diversity and to the fact that many species remain undescribed. The ELSC fauna are taxonomically similar to fauna from other biogeographic provinces. One such example are species are shrimp in the family Alvinocarididae. They have so far been found only at gas/oil seeps and hydrothermal vents worldwide. I am describing, with a colleague from France, a new species of Alvinocaris from the ELSC that is morphologically most similar to A. lusca from the Galapagos Rift Zone and East Pacific Rise. This species phylogenetic placement, based only on the COI gene, is somewhat obscured and awaits further phylogenetic analysis with a wider array of nuclear and mitochondrial genes. Another interesting taxonomic group are the cnidarian fauna of the ELSC. The Cnidaria have not been reported to make up a significant portion of the community at vents in the Pacific and Atlantic Oceans. Eight species from five biogeographic provinces have been described. Only recently have they garnered attention as dense communities of anemones been observed at Central Indian Ridge vents (Van Dover et al. 2001). Our recent expeditions to the ELSC have discovered another densely populated community of mixed anemones and zoanthids. With colleagues from the Ohio State University, I am describing seven new species of anemone and one new species of zoanthid. The zoanthid and four of the anemone species live within the influence of hydrothermal vent flow. An additional species is found both near vents and in the ambient deep sea community. The remaining 2 anemone species are found in the ambient deep sea community only. The proximity of these cnidarians to vent effluent suggests a link to chemoautotrophic primary production. The additions of these new species of shrimp and cnidarians from ELSC fills gaps in the western Pacific back-arc basins that aid in our understanding of the biogeography of hydrothermal vent fauna.

An additional study I have undertaken is a stable isotope bioassay for primary production of particulate organic matter (POM) at methane seeps in the Gulf of Mexico using filter-feeding taxa. Previous studies have focused on primary production from the standpoint of the chemoautotrophic symbioses or free-living bacteria found in and on top of the sediment at seeps. Little attention has been given to the role of seeps in creating POM that enters the water column, despite the observations of suspension-feeding invertebrates at and near seep communities (i.e. tubeworm aggregations, mussel beds). Since filter-feeders directly uptake the POM in the water column, their tissue stable isotope values are point estimates of the available POM at that time. Stable carbon, nitrogen and sulfur isotope ratios for methanotrophy at seeps are distinct from photosynthetic-derived nutrients that fall down from surface water. We can exploit this difference in food source “signatures” to approximate the input of seep-derived primary production of POM relative to photosynthetic primary production of POM. I used a 2 end-member stable isotope mixing model to approximate the relative contribution of seep-derived nutrients to the POM pool at a methane seeps. Interestingly, about ¼ of the POM can be attributed to methane seep primary production of POM. This is my first chapter, so it will comprise the next edition of Dissertation Blogging!

**Photographic images are copyright C.R. Fisher/Ridge2000 Program**

Literature Cited

Bergquist DC, Eckner JT, Urcuyo IA, Cordes EE, Hourdez S, Macko SA, Fisher CR (2007) Using stable isotopes and quantitative community characteristics to determine a local hydrothermal vent food web. Marine Ecology Progress Series 330:49-65

Bruno JF, Bertness MD (2001) Habitat modification and facilitation in benthic marine communities. In: Bertness MD, Steven D. Gaines, Mark E. Hay (ed) Marine Community Ecology. Sinauer Associates, Inc., Sunderland, MA, p 201-218


Bruno JF, Stachowicz JJ, Bertness MD (2003) Inclusion of facilitation into ecological theory. TREE 18:119-125


Childress JJ, Fisher CR (1992) The biology of hydrothermal vent animals: physiology, biochemistry and autotrophic symbioses. Oceanography and Marine Biology: An Annual Review 30:337-441


Dayton PK (1972) Toward an understanding of community resilience and the potential effects of enrichments to the benthos at McMurdo Sound. In: Proceedings of the Colloquium on Conservation Problems in Antarctica, p 81-96


Fisher CR, Childress JJ, Macko SA, Brooks JM (1994) Nutritional interactions in Galapagos Rift hydrothermal vent communities: inferences from stable carbon and nitrogen isotope analyses. Marine Ecology Progress Series 103:45-55


Govenar B, Fisher CR (2007) Experimental evidence of habitat provision by aggregations of Riftia pachyptila at hydrothermal vents on the East Pacific Rise. Marine Ecology 28:3-14


Jannasch HW (1985) The chemosynthetic support of life and the microbial diversity at deep-sea hydrothermal vents. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B 225:277-297


Johnson KS, Childress JJ, Beehler CL, Sakamoto CM (1994) Biogeochemistry of hydrothermal vent mussel communities: the deep-sea analogue to the intertidal zone. Deep-Sea Research I 41:993-1011


Johnson KS, Childress JJ, Hessler RR, Sakamoto-Arnold CM, Beehler CL (1988) Chemical and biological interactions in the Rose Garden hydrothermal vent field, Galapagos spreading center. Deep Sea Research Part A Oceanographic Research Papers 35:1723-1744


Shank TM, Fornari DJ, Von Damm KL, Lilley MD, Haymon RM, Lutz RA (1998) Temporal and spatial patterns of biological community development at nascent deep-sea hydrothermal vents (9deg.50'N, East Pacific Rise). Deep-Sea Research II 45:465-515


Tunnicliffe V (1991) The biology of hydrothermal vents: ecology and evolution. Oceanography and Marine Biology: An Annual Review 29:319-407


Van Dover CL, Fry B (1989) Stable isotopic compositions of hydrothermal vent organisms. Marine Biology 102:257-263


Van Dover CL, Fry B (1994) Microorganisms as food resources at deep-sea hydrothermal vents. Limnology and Oceanography 39:51-57


Van Dover CL, Humphris SE, Fornari D, Cavanaugh CM, Collier R, Goffredi SK, Hashimoto J, Lilley MD, Reysenbach AL, Shank TM, Von Damm KL, Banta A, Gallant RM, Götz D, Green D, Hall J, Harmer TL, Hurtado LA, Johnson P, McKiness ZP, Meredith C, Olson E, Pan IL, Turnipseed M, Won Y, Young III CR, Vrijenhoek RC (2001) Biogeography and ecological setting of Indian Ocean hydrothermal vents. Science 294:818-823

_____________________________________________________________
*This post was updated on Nov. 30 after I made substantial changes to my thesis proposal after reading comments from my advisor.

Monday, November 5, 2007

Exploding Shells

These snails, Alviniconcha hessleri are from hydrothermal vents at the Lau Back-Arc Basin (1800-2800m depth) where I am doing my PhD research. They are interesting for many reasons, one that they are chemoautotrophic with a highly reduced digestive tract and depend on endosymbiotic sulfide-oxidizing bacteria in its gills for the majority of its nutrition. They can get up to fist size and form dense aggregations of up to 100+ individuals in roughly 1/4 meter-squared. Research currently in review from a lab at UC-Santa Barbara has determined A. hessleri to have some serious fast metabolism and have the highest thermal-chemical tolerance of all the chemoautotrophic fauna at the Lau Basin vents. It a very interesting mollusc and a very beautiful one too. Below is a picture of an air-dried one that last several months before peeling away. It was taken by my wife, who is a photographer.



Notice their thin shell and spiny periostracum. The periostracum is an organic layer laid down over the calcareous layer of the shell. For more information about Alviniconcha, I wrote an article on this species when I was writing for Deep Sea News. Below, you'll see pictures of what happens to the shells after time takes it's toll. Pictures taken by myself (obviously not a photographer) in a box I put them in to dry. This was about 2 days after 3 hour and 24 hour mineral oil treatments.




My question to the malacologically-inclined community is this: any suggestions for dry preservation of rare deep-sea shells? No matter what I try, they end up blowing up. I've tried letting them dry out in the open air, dry out in a drying oven (60C), spraying them bumloads of shellac (which just slows down the time to kaboom), and drowning them in mineral for a few hours to a day (see last pictures for the outcome). Using a drying oven, I heard a pop after 30-60 minutes and found shell fragments and periostracum spines all over the mussel body tissue I had in there for condition analyses. Drying in the open air results in a slow (over the course of a few weeks) peeling back of the aperature until the tension breaks the shell. Shellac only works for a couple months and mineral oil not at all. I have another shell in mineral oil for a week now so I'll take it out and drain it and see if it explodes too.

Any suggestions are welcome. I'm sure there are some shell collectors among my readership. I only have about 20-30 shells left so I don't want to experiment too much further. They are left over from failing to reject a certain null hypothesis of mine. I will blog on that later, even with data! It all boils down to 1.5 years of work relegated to a sentence in the materials and methods and maybe a couple in the discussion.

Monday, July 16, 2007

My PhD in Bean-Counting


Photo courtesy of C.R. Fisher, Penn State

Pascal over at Research at a Snail's Pace posted a spontaneous "8 things" blog meme. This post started as a comment that I just decided to post here, mostly for bragging rights. He states
"I have counted more than 10,000 individual snails and sieved through more than 200 kilograms of mud for my dissertation."


Impressive young Jedi. Let me just recall my last two field seasons of JUST THE GASTROPODS ONLY (don't even get me started on the freaking polychaetes!).

Lepetodrilus schrolli-37,666 (321.67g)
Olgasolarus tollmanni-7,114 (229.88g)
Symmetromphalus sp. nov.-713 (14.08g)
Bathyacmaea sp. nov.-424 (1.36g)
Pseudorimula marianae-72 (0.3g)
Desbruyeresia cancellata-70 (1.12g)
Shinkailepas sp. nov.-43 (0.98g)
Eosipho desbruyeresi-11 (273.57g)
Provanna buccinoides-6 (0.75g)
Bruciella globulus-6 (0.01g)
Phymorhynchus sp.-4 (0.16g)
Lurifax sp.-4 (<0.01g)
Pachydermia sculpta-3 (<0.01g)
Venstia tricarinata-3 (<0.01g)
Planordibella depressa-2 (<0.01g)
Leptogyra inflata-1 (0.01g)
Laeviphitus sp.-1 (<0.01g)
TOTAL # - 46,143 (843.89g)


These snails and limpets, by the way, are from the Lau Basin hydrothermal vent are are associated with communities of chemoautotrophic mussel (Bathymodiolus brevior) and snails (Alviniconcha hessleri and Ifremeria nautilei, counted >1000 each for sure). As an evolutionary biology/statistician friend of mine says, my dissertation is in bean-counting.

The purpose of all this counting and weighing though is to test hypotheses about how communities associated with chemoautotrophic foundation fauna are structured. At this particular locality there are three dense bed-forming foundation species. Each foundation species forms the structure or substrate for a community of associated organisms. I'm in the process of analyzing my data from 2 expeditions right now and will keep you posted on the progress and results!

Initial results look pretty interesting though, some clear cut patterns. For instance, one foundation species, A. hessleri, inhabits the hottest (up to 37 C perhaps) and most toxic (highest concentrations of sulfide) parts of the vents. Its community of associated fauna is very much different than the communities associated with I. nautilei and B. brevior. Both of the latter inhabit low temperature areas with lower concentrations of sulfide (the energy source for the endosymbiotic bacteria inside the chemoautotrophs). In fact their communities are very similar and overlap in Bray-Curtis nonmetric multidimensional scaling plots.

Thursday, July 12, 2007

The Eye of the Shrimp

*Not to be confused with the hit song by Survivor.

Photo is from here (in japanese)


The vent shrimp, Rimicaris exoculata (literally the Rift-shrimp deprived of eyes), swarms hydrothermal chimneys, with temperatures reaching over 350C, en masse in the darkness of the deep sea. It has a certain peculiarity in that its eyes are completely absent yet there is a high concentration of the visual pigment, rhodopsin, in a dorsal "eyespot" beneath a transparent cuticle of the carapace. Other vent shrimp, such as individuals in all other alvinocarid genera, do retain the eye, though it tends to be reduced and fused together. The anatomy of this eye has been studied in detail and several authors have hypothesized that it can detect "black-body" radiation, or thermal radiation given off by the vents at around 350C.

Figure is from Nuckley et al. 1996

Pelli & Chamberlain (1989) actually calculated out whether or not R. exoculata could see this black-body radiation given the concentration of rhodopsin it has and the radiation properties of 350C hydrothermal vents. Using alot of physics and math, their conclusion is:
"... 50pmol of rhodopsin present in the shrimp eye will yield approximately 1,600 thermal isomerizations per second. To detect the 350C vent, the shrimp would have to discriminate a signal-plus-noise isomerization rate of 1,800+1,600=3,400 per second from a noise-alone rate of 1,600 per second. A brief integration time of only 20ms would yield a decision variable with a signal-to-noise ratio of 6.4.[...] This would allow the shrimp to detect correctly the lethal hot water 99.9% of the time, and mistake ambient for hot water only 2% of the time."
They determined that the shrimp's peak wavelength was around 500nm, pointing out that the luminance of the vent is just below the threshold for a dark-adapted human. Nuckley et al. 1996 concluded from their examination of retina:
"The structural changes observed in the retina of Rimicaris sp. might be expected in an animal that is adapting to a dim-light environment... and are consistent with the changes we have observed in other hydrothermal vent shrimp. In general, an animal's eye continues to enlarge as the environment becomes dimmer and dimmer until the "quit point" is reached where exploitation of light in the environment becomes impossible [...]. In animals that adapt to the darkness beyond the quit point, the eye shrinks or disappears altogether. The eyes of the [alvinocaridid] shrimp that live on the sides of black smoker chimneys at sites along the Mid-Atlantic Ridge have all enlarged... however the eye of the predator Alvinocaris markensis, which lives at the base of these chimneys, seems to be in the process of evolving past the quit point [...]."
An interesting point also is that Rimicaris farms and harvests sulfide-loving bacteria under its carapace. The bacteria are where the temperatures are hot because that is where the sulfide is. Therefore the shrimp would have to make periodic excursions into hot water to get more bacteria to graze. This eyespot appears to be able to sense the thermal radiation given off by vents and use it to as a navigational cue utilizing the light-sensing organ in addition to using it to sense where it may get scorched! I have sense some alvinocaridids with what looks like burnt off tails. These alvinocaridids do not have the dorsal eyespot that Rimicaris does. Chamberlain 2000 reviewed vision in vent shrimp. He compared the image-forming eye of shallow water shrimp to the photodetection eye of vent shrimp, as well as comparing juvenile to adult vent shrimp. A very interesting insight was that
"the retinal structure of juvenile vent shrimp resembles much more closely that of the imaging eyes of surface-dwelling species... than it does the retinal structure of adult vent shrimp ...these data suggest that vent shrimp have evolved from ancestors that lived in a visual environment bright enough for them to use pattern vision, since the juveniles still show this kind of retinal structure,"